Review: Maria Williams: Lezzie McGuire – satirical, chaotic, vulnerable, and side-splittingly funny

Ruth Agnew reviews Maria Williams: Lezzie McGuire, at Little Andromeda, Friday 13 November 2026.

Disarmingly honest, sidesplittingly funny, and completely chaotic: Maria Williams’ Lezzie McGuire is an unexpected delight. Tracing her delayed journey through discovering a new ethnicity, a new allergy, and a new sexuality, Williams transformed personal history into pure, collective joy.

You may be familiar with Maria Williams from The Traitors NZ, where she used her neurodivergent superpowers to identify all three traitors, or perhaps her appearances on Guy Montgomery’s Guy Mont- Spelling Bee, where she revealed her inability to spell her own name once prevented her from entering Vietnam. But if you really want to know her, you need to get yourself to Lezzie McGuire, a comedic exploration of her journey from faux-Italian Catholic schoolgirl to 30-something lesbian coeliac.

Christchurch people know, the most important piece of information when getting to know someone is what school they went to. Williams left the social safe haven of St Joseph’s, a small Catholic primary school, to attend the wild and worldly state secondary school, Nayland College, aka Gayland. Despite spending her formative teenage years at a school rumoured to teach students more LGBTQ+ than NCEA, Williams completed Year 13 without realising she was a lesbian. She did, however, find a mentor who would come to be an integral figure in her coming-of-age story: Lizzie McGuire.

Lizzie McGuire was an early 2000s American sitcom about a clumsy middle schooler (played by Hilary Duff) trying to find her place in the world. What made an impact on Williams though, was the spin-off film, The Lizzie McGuire Movie (2003). In the film, Lizzie McGuire is on a school trip to Rome following middle school graduation, where she briefly becomes an Italian pop star. Clearly, totally relatable for a kid from Nelson who didn’t make the cut for her school’s Stage Challenge entry.

That’s the premise for Lezzie McGuire, but the magic of this show comes from Williams’ unbridled sense of fun and unpredictable shifts in topic and logic. It is hard to explain how we went from standing at the gates of Nayland College wearing a giant backpack and WWJD bracelet to the entire audience karaoke singing “Teenage Dirtbag” to an empty stage, but I’m glad I was along for the ride. The heart of the show lies in the raw, shambolic sincerity of a delayed coming-of-age story, balancing sharp satire with moments of genuine vulnerability.

Lezzie McGuire leans heavily into deeply funny, early-2000s teen rom-com memories that struck a chord with anyone who fumbled their way into adulthood long after high school ended. Williams treats the crowd like an intimate room of old friends, making crowd participation feel organic and part of an inside joke. The props, sound and visual aids are reminiscent of pre-teen art projects, adding to the unpretentious, relaxed atmosphere.

Lezzie McGuire proves that relatable teen nostalgia, 30-something self-discovery and unfettered comedic instincts make for incredible theatre. If you missed her at Little Andromeda, keep an eye out for wherever this “hot mess” travels next.

Leave a Reply